Nintendo is commonly perceived as a master of vertical integration. From system manufacturing to software creation, Nintendo manages the entire process internally. Such total dominance is uncommon in either technology and media; maybe only giants like Disney or Apple come close.
The Glaring Anomaly: Pokémon
However, there exists one massive exception to this rule. Pokémon is arguably Nintendo's biggest property. Some estimates, albeit hard to verify, suggest it is the top-earning media franchise of all time. This wealth flows from omnipresent merchandise, game sales, and a booming card game business. But interestingly, Pokémon is not wholly Nintendo's property.
The mainline Pokémon video games are published only on Nintendo systems, but they are developed by the external developer Game Freak. Jointly with Game Freak and Creatures Inc. (the company behind the trading card game), Nintendo is a part-owner of The Pokémon Company. This entity oversees the worldwide licensing business that brings in billions. Even, the massive hit Pokémon Go was created and launched by third-party companies under a license from The Pokémon Company, operating at a significant remove from Nintendo's direct supervision.
A Precedent of External Success
For a business noted for its strict processes, this relationship seems inconsistent. Yet, Pokémon was not the first time an outside game drove Nintendo's fortunes.
In 1989, Nintendo launched the revolutionary Game Boy. However, its in-house teams had not yet found the perfect game for it. The answer came from outside: Tetris. Nintendo's fierce quest to secure the licensing for the Game Boy port of Tetris is legendary in the gaming industry. The triumph of Tetris solidified the Game Boy's place and paved the path for Nintendo's long-term dominance in handheld devices. This handheld business offered crucial support during difficult periods for its console business and eventually led to the hybrid Switch.
Despite masterful ports of its flagship franchises, a completely innovative handheld concept was not conceived in-house. Instead, that inspiration originated with ex- game journalist Satoshi Tajiri, creator of Game Freak. After learning that Game Boys could be connected via a cable, he envisioned trading digital beings, inspired by his youthful memories of collecting bugs.
Game Freak pitched the concept to Nintendo, which quickly embraced it. Yet, it required a long time for Pocket Monsters to evolve into the sprawling RPG launched in 1996. Another few years went by before the games, coupled with a trading card game and an anime, burst into a global phenomenon. Pokémon extended the life of the Game Boy well into its lengthy reign and effectively guaranteed Nintendo's financial security.
Why Didn't Buy It All?
It may appear strange that Nintendo did not move to fully purchase Game Freak and Pokémon when its colossal success became clear. This is precisely the sort of action a corporation like Disney would have made. Instead, the three-way alliance between Nintendo, Game Freak, and Creatures was formalized as early as 1998. This developed into The Pokémon Company, which now handles the global franchise.
This approach is not completely foreign to Nintendo. But, Pokémon's scale was unprecedented. So why not seize the entire prize? It is possible that creators Satoshi Tajiri and Tsunekazu Ishihara were not prepared to sell their creation. It is also possible that Nintendo's leadership, from the stern Hiroshi Yamauchi to the astute Satoru Iwata, made a conscious decision not to seek complete acquisition.
The Advantages of Distance
In hindsight, this partnership may have been remarkably wise. Would Nintendo have authorized the enormous array of branded products or dived into the card market with such fervor? The Pokémon Company, operating with a measure of autonomy, could execute a voracious plan to capture global attention and spending.
Nintendo benefited immensely from this bonanza while having to manage the day-to-day or endanger its family-friendly image. When concerns arose about the trading card game impact, the scrutiny was directed elsewhere from Nintendo. Even, the sometimes variable reception of modern Game Freak games is a reputational cost mostly carried by The Pokémon Company, not Nintendo itself.
A Enduring Symbiosis
In many ways, this arrangement reflects a core Nintendo philosophy. The firm is known for not tampering with what works.|Nintendo generally avoids needless